The National Women’s Soccer League (NWSL), one of the top women’s professional soccer leagues in the world, has been rocked by allegations of sexual misconduct, inappropriate and homophobic comments, and other questionable behavior as detailed in a report by The Athletic.
The revelations have resulted in a coach’s termination, the resignation of the league’s commissioner and the opening of several investigations by different governing bodies as the women’s soccer community processes the fallout and begins to outline a path forward.
In the Sept. 30 story published in The Athletic, two players, Sinead Farrelly and Mana Shim, accused long-time professional women’s soccer coach Paul Riley of sexual coercion and harassment. Riley, who denied the allegations to The Athletic, was let go from his position as North Carolina Courage’s head coach hours after the report was published. A day later NWSL commissioner Lisa Baird resigned.
Current and former players spoke out about the accusations, offering support to the two players who stepped forward and demanding accountability and action from the NWSL. The league proceeded to cancel a weekend slate of matches as it met with its players regarding the next steps to be taken.
NWSL leadership and the league’s owners came under fire for their handling of the case exposed by The Athletic, leading to questions about the league’s culture and its ability to protect its players. Riley was rehired in the NWSL mere months after a 2015 investigation by the Portland Thorns found breaches in club policy that led to the decision not to renew his contract. Then earlier this year, Farrelly and Shim also filed formal complaints requesting a new league investigation into Riley, but their claims didn’t result in any action from the NWSL.
Below is the latest on the scandal which surfaced just days after the head coach of one of the other 10 clubs, Washington’s Richie Burke, was fired for cause amid alleged misconduct that led to one former Spirit player, Kaiya McCullough, speaking out. Also, OL Reign coach Farid Benstiti resigned in July after he was the subject of a player complaint, according to the Washington Post.
What is being alleged?
In The Athletic story, Farrelly alleges Riley coerced her into having sex in 2011 when she was a member of WPS club Philadelphia Independence and later in 2012 as a member of the New York Fury of the WPSL Elite league. The report goes on to detail other instances of inappropriate conduct and comments by Riley, including a 2015 incident with the NWSL’s Portland Thorns in which, according to the players, he allegedly pressured teammates Farrelly and Shim to kiss in order to avoid a conditioning drill for the team. Riley denied the accusations in a statement to The Athletic calling them “completely untrue.”
Shim filed a complaint with the Thorns’ front office at the end of the 2015 season and, after an investigation, Portland didn’t renew Riley’s contract. Thorns owner Merritt Paulson told The Athletic that the results of the probe were shared with the NWSL league office though the details were not made public. Riley was hired a few months later by the NWSL’s Western New York Flash, a club that later relocated to North Carolina and became the Courage.
After the NWSL adopted a new anti-harassment policy earlier in 2021, The Athletic reported that both Farrelly and Shim requested the league conduct a new investigation into Riley; however, the league’s commissioner, Lisa Baird, informed them that the 2015 complaint was “investigated to conclusion.”
FIFA, U.S. Soccer, NWSL open investigations
All three bodies are launching investigations into the allegations detailed in The Athletic.
FIFA: The world governing body announced on Oct. 1 that its judicial arm is “actively looking into the matter and have opened a preliminary investigation.”
U.S. Soccer Federation: The national governing body has retained a former U.S. attorney and Deputy Attorney General of the USA, Sally Q. Yates, to conduct an independent investigation. “She will be given full autonomy, access and the necessary resources to follow the facts and evidence wherever they may lead.”
NWSL: The embattled league will now be led by a three-person executive committee while it seeks a new commissioner. It has retained its own firm, Covington & Burling, to oversee investigations and to make recommendations for reform. Its scope will include reopening the 2015 investigation into Riley and any other past complaints made in the NWSL.
What have the NWSL and its clubs said?
Hours after The Athletic article was published, the North Carolina Courage terminated Riley and U.S. Soccer suspended his coaching license:
Then NWSL commissioner Lisa Baird issued a statement announcing a series of steps being taken by the league in response to the report, including mandating training and background checks for team and league staff, and the introduction of a system to allow for anonymous reporting.
The Portland Thorns issued a statement clarifying the club’s actions at the end of Riley’s tenure. The team didn’t bring Riley back in 2015, but the details of the investigation were not revealed until The Athletic’s report. The club apologized to the players “for our role in the abuse they detailed.”
We want to thank Mana Shim and Sinead Farrelly for bravely speaking out and fully apologize to them for our role in the abuse they detailed.
— Portland Thorns FC (@ThornsFC) September 30, 2021
As part of the match cancellation announcement, Baird also took “full responsibility for the role I have played” prior to tendering her resignation:
“This week, and much of this season, has been incredibly traumatic for our players and staff, and I take full responsibility for the role I have played. I am so sorry for the pain so many are feeling. Recognizing that trauma, we have decided not to take the field this weekend to give everyone some space to reflect. Business as usual isn’t our concern right now. Our entire league has a great deal of healing to do, and our players deserve so much better. We have made this decision in collaboration with our players association and this pause will be the first step as we collectively work to transform the culture of this league, something that is long overdue.”
Current & former players speak out
Several high-profile players and former stars have voiced their support for the players who stepped forward, and demanded the league do more to protect them in the future.
U.S. national team star Alex Morgan, who played a key role in the push for the NWSL to institute its anti-harassment policy, shared a Twitter thread, including an email exchange between Farrelly and league commissioner Baird.
(1/3)The league was informed of these allegations multiple times and refused multiple times to investigate the allegations. The league must accept responsibility for a process that failed to protect its own players from this abuse. https://t.co/KDRBhhVBcT
— Alex Morgan (@alexmorgan13) September 30, 2021
Megan Rapinoe, Meghan Klingenberg, and former U.S. women’s national team stars Abby Wambach and Julie Foudy had strong words for the league, its owners and former commissioner: “Burn it all down. Let all their heads roll,” wrote Rapinoe.
Men, protecting men, who are abusing women. I’ll say it again, men, protecting men, who are ABUSING WOMEN. Burn it all down. Let all their heads roll. https://t.co/iHg3JlVVe0
— Megan Rapinoe (@mPinoe) September 30, 2021
Sinead, Mana, and Kaiya,
I believe every single word you’ve said.
I’m furious but not surprised.
Your pain and bravery has wrecked and ignited me today.
Thank you for leading.
I plan to follow.
— Abby Wambach (@AbbyWambach) September 30, 2021
A league for women. Yet @NWSL fails to protect women. And then tries to continue to sweep it under the rug. Support these players. Believe these players. Protect these players. Transparency, accountability NOW.
— Julie Foudy (@JulieFoudy) September 30, 2021
Protect the players. Protect women. It’s everyone’s responsibility to hold the standards and enforce accountability. Why are we still dealing with these mostly male transgressions? This is unacceptable. @NWSL
— Christine Sinclair (@sincy12) September 30, 2021
(2/2) I’m saddened by the prevalence of this type of behavior in our profession due to the lack of oversight and accountability in our league. The lasting emotional toll of abuse on players not only affects their careers but their entire lives moving forward.
— Sofia Huerta (@schuerta) September 30, 2021
The players’ union, the NWSL Players Association, was quick with its response to the report by The Athletic, leading the charge to cancel the matches on Oct. 1-2. It also provided players an anonymous hotline for reporting abuse and made a sports psychologist available to them.
Former U.S. women’s national team star Christie Pearce Rampone deferred her Hall of Fame induction in light of the news:
NEWS: Christie Pearce Rampone has chosen to defer her induction until 2022. The NSHOF fully supports Christie’s decision & looks forward to honoring her & her historic achievements at next year’s induction ceremony. pic.twitter.com/j5W6wNws6D
— U.S. Soccer (@ussoccer) October 2, 2021
The president of Racing Louisville Brad Estes and Gotham FC head coach Scott Parkinson joined the chorus of voices demanding change:
We MUST protect our players!
Enough is enough!
— Scott Parkinson (@parkinson_scott) September 30, 2021
“…It’s going to take real work and humility to effect the change these athletes deserve. Now more than ever, we are committed to this effort, and we fully support our players.”
— Racing Louisville FC (@RacingLouFC) October 1, 2021
Portland Timbers players were among the first in MLS to make public their support: